Will the Influencer Marketing bubble burst?

Will the Influencer Marketing bubble burst?

It seems that influencer marketing has been having a rough time of late. With influencer fraud, ‘fake followers’ and monetised marriage proposals dominating the headlines, is the influencer marketing bubble about to burst?


Here are a few points marketers need to take note of in order for influencer marketing to survive – at least on Instagram.


It’s nothing new.


Truth is, influencer marketing is nothing new. It’s existed in the form of celebrity endorsements and athlete sponsorship's for decades. Now, with social media there’s an opportunity to get just as many eyes on our product as we see in traditional forms of advertising like television and print and because everyone has a smartphone there’s no reason why your average Joe can’t start to make money from their reach.


The reason ‘influencer marketing’ has worked so well in television, print and digital is because marketers can make informed business decisions through key insights that link directly to ROI such as reach, readership, viewability and circulation. When it comes to social media platforms like Instagram, we’re often left in the dark as these stats can be a little more difficult to get a hold of.


Get your hands on the right data


Because follower size and (once upon a time) likes are the only pieces of public information available to most of us they have naturally become the traded metric and now with all this talk of fake followers, pods and like farms it’s clear that this is a flawed way of assessing an influencer’s value.


For influencer marketing to thrive on platforms like Instagram marketers need to treat influencers the same way they do on other traditional forms of advertising where there is an expectation that they see relevant and accurate data to help them make huge spending decisions.


It’s common to use third-party analytics platforms to find this data however, in August last year Instagram made changes to its API and many of these platforms lost access to influencer’s data. In order to keep their business afloat, these platforms have largely resorted to other far less ethical (or legal) ways of getting it – this data is often outdated and incorrect.


The only way to get credible data is directly from the influencer through free, independent platforms like Q-83 where influencers opt in to share in-depth, real-time insights on their audience demographics and reach.


Just like traditional forms of advertising where these metrics are ‘business-as-usual’ and transparently shared with brands to help them make decisions, influencers should be no different. When evaluating an influencer, think, if they aren’t willing to share that information with you, are they really worth the investment?


Bigger isn’t always better


For a while now we’ve been led to believe that the more followers an influencer has, the more people will see their content and therefore the more value they bring to a brand. Wrong.


There’s two issues with this. One is that just like a billboard it’s important to know how many people will actually see your content and of those that have the chance to see it, how many choose to act. The number of followers someone has is not an audience, those that see it, is. It’s common to see influencers with 138K followers only reach 38K users and influencers with only 9K followers reach over 89K users - my bet is that one of them is getting paid a lot more than the other while reaching far fewer users.


The other is that influencers should be chosen for their audience first. If you’re a local coffee shop in Surry Hills and an influencer with a relatively small following is a coffee lover who lives in Surry Hills, chances are their followers might be coffee lovers in Surry Hills too - that’s a great match. On the other hand if you’re an Australian bikini brand and you’re advertising through a supermodel (who looks great in your product) with over 1 million male followers based out of Brazil, I’m not sure how many bikinis you are likely to sell.


Influencer marketing isn’t going anywhere. The fact is though, that if influencers aren’t able (or willing) to transparently share their metrics with brands then it’s going to become increasingly difficult to forecast an ROI and justify spending large budgets. Instagram is one of the largest influencer marketing platforms right now but if marketers can’t get their hands on credible data they will be forced to move on to other platforms where they can.


About the Author


Anthony RichardsonAnthony Richardson Founder and Managing Director of Q-83, the world-leading influencer metric sharing company. Anthony works closely with major publishing houses and regulation authorities across the UK and Australia.


1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (3 votes, average: 5.00 out of 5)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

business plan template

Get Instant Access to the Business Plan Template that has helped thousands of Business Owners in every sector plan and grow their business.

Learn More
fees and benefits

Our Programs start from as little as $10 a day making it affordable for all business types.

Learn More

Top Rated Articles

How your company can adapt to the Digital Revolution

Over the last couple of years, technological innovation has brought about a rapid change in the customer service landsca


Will Marketing Automation Help Your Business Grow?

Marketing automation software can benefit your business in a number of ways. It is a great way to increase traffic, enco


How CRM Can Maximize Customer Lifetime Value (CLV)

"Keep your customers always on the frontline," this is a key philosophy to running a successful business. Customers are


Recently Viewed

The Different Hats That Every Entrepreneur Wears

Most business owners like yourself spend a large amount of time and energy in your business and are very closely involve


4 Crucial Elements of Website Readability that Impact Conversions

One of the most important aspects of any website is content. You've probably heard the phrase "content is king", made fa


6 Sydney Business Meetup Groups you Should be a Part Of

Being a member of a meetup group in Sydney is a great way of networking with people from your field. You can find new

  • Over the past 6 months the incredible team at MMP have supported us to shift our attitude towards our business & month on month our revenue is increasing to the point we will be able to employ additional staff to support our business goals long into the future. Do not regret our decision one single bit!

    • Emma Reece

  • Working with my coach has enabled me to see the areas where my business is failing. This was pretty confronting to me to be honest. MMP has the tools to improve these areas and the guidance on how to implement them.

    • Sharon Robinson

  • I have been working with Max My Profit for approx 3 years now, and over that time I have learnt a lot of things about not only what it takes to run a business, but I have also learnt things about myself. I don't believe i'd be the person or have the business I have today if it wasn't for Max My Profit and our Business Excelerator. Great team to work with if you want to take your business serious!

    • Ben Choy

  • As a new client for Max My Profit (MMP) it has taken no time at all to realise the benefits of business coaching. Despite many years of senior management experience starting a new business requires best practice systems and processes built on a solid platform of detailed planning. I look forward to the benefits of adopting the formula being shared by MMP.

    • Campbell MacLeod

  • Max My Profit Are truly awesome at what they do. They have helped me over the past 12 months to get off the tools in my business and start working on my business. I am looking forward to 2019 with enthusiasm not concern. Thanks so much.

    • Aaron Kemp

  • If you are committed to Growth the Max My Profit Team has the tools and expertise to excelerate all areas of your life. They Care, They Listen, They Understand You as an Individual first then they focus on Your business. Thank you Max My Profit my rating is a 6/5 - Kindest Regards The Mr Handyfix Team

    • Catherine Kavadas

  • The team at Max My Profit are an absolute pleasure to deal with. I love working with a team who is on top of what they are doing and have a clear view of what they are working on with you and helping ensure you get to the end goal.

    • Lauren Watts

  • I have been working with MaxMyProfit over the years and what they do for SME's in growing their business is fantastic. Also due to there knowledge and their supporting material for companies across the 5 lifestyle stages and assisting them through this process day in day out is extremely comforting as a small business owner and have referred them many businesses over the years.

    • Steve Laingy

  • Working with a business coach from MaxMyProfit has been one of the best things I have done for my business. I had several other coaches before MaxMyProfit but these guys are a step above the others. I have seen a significant increase in sales, now have a business that can run itself and the coaching program has paid for itself many times over.

    • Matthew Kitchin

  • Much more than just business coaches. There is an absolute treasure chest of business knowledge in their members site.

    • Iain Campbell

  • Max My Profit are unique as they really partner with you to develop and implement a plan that will drive success for the business. I was hesitant to proceed as previous business coaches tell you what to do and rely on you to implement.

    • Michael de Haan

  • I attended one of Max My Profits introductory events in Melbourne. Having been an accountant for almost 30 years, I was somewhat sceptical. Boy was I wrong. I not only enjoyed the presentation, but I gleaned so much from just that session.

    • Daniel Odd

  • These guys are an absolute wealth of knowledge for Small Business. The programme and support networks they have set up ensure learn more every day and can take your business from good to great. Thanks so much.

    • John Butler